http://tinyurl.com/ckdjq9m
My understanding of the system is that GIB should bid 2NT. Is it bidding 2S because of some sort of simulation?
Page 1 of 1
System fail or just judgement?
#3
Posted 2012-September-15, 16:14
I don't like the 1NT bid; I think South should bid 2♣ over North's 1♠.
The explanation of 1NT includes the possibility that South is 5-5 in hearts and a minor; I think that would be horrible. But, it also says that South has at least 2 of each suit, which precludes him from being 5-5. But then again, he doesn't actually have 2+ diamonds, does he?
The explanation of 1NT includes the possibility that South is 5-5 in hearts and a minor; I think that would be horrible. But, it also says that South has at least 2 of each suit, which precludes him from being 5-5. But then again, he doesn't actually have 2+ diamonds, does he?
#4
Posted 2012-September-16, 14:19
Others 1NT rebids seem fixed. Maybe 1♥-1♠-1N slipped. Fixed in next update to show - -- 2-3 ♣; 2-3 ♦; 5 ♥; 2-3 ♠; 12-14 HCP
Page 1 of 1