...How did he speak with his two daughters about the election results, about the post-election reports of racial incidents? What I say to them is that people are complicated, Obama told me. Societies and cultures are really complicated. . . . This is not mathematics; this is biology and chemistry. These are living organisms, and its messy. And your job as a citizen and as a decent human being is to constantly affirm and lift up and fight for treating people with kindness and respect and understanding. And you should anticipate that at any given moment theres going to be flare-ups of bigotry that you may have to confront, or may be inside you and you have to vanquish. And it doesnt stop. . . . You dont get into a fetal position about it. You dont start worrying about apocalypse. You say, O.K., where are the places where I can push to keep it moving forward.
For the Democratic Party, these questions have a strategic dimension. After Obama and Clinton, the Party bench is thin. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are hardly young. Obama insisted that there were gifted Democratic politicians out there, but that many were new to the scene. He mentioned Kamala Harris, the new senator from California; Pete Buttigieg, a gay Rhodes Scholar and Navy veteran who has twice been elected mayor of South Bend, Indiana; Tim Kaine; and Senator Michael Bennet, of Colorado.
And Obama related the Partys losses this year to previous setbacksand recoveries. Some of my staff are really young, so they dont remember this, Obama said. They remember my speech from the Boston Convention, in 2004, because they uploaded it on YouTube or something, but they might have been fifteen when it happened. Well, thats the election that John Kerry lost. George Bush was reëlected. Tom Daschle, the Democratic leader in the Senate, was defeated. The Senate went Republican. The House was Republican. Me and Ken Salazar, of Colorado, were the only two Democrats nationally who won. It was a very similar period to where we are right now. Two years later, Democrats had won back the Senate; I think they had won back the House. And four years later I was the President of the United States.
So this notion somehow that these irreversible tides have been unleashed, I think, surrenders our agency. Its easier than us saying, Huh, we missed that, we messed that up, weve got to do better in how we organize. We have to stop relying on a narrow targeting of our base turnout strategy if we want to govern. . . . Setting aside the results of this election, Democrats are well positioned to keep winning Presidential elections just by appealing to the base. And, each year, the demographic improves.
To put it more bluntly than Obama did, the nonwhite percentage of the population will continue to increase. But well keep on getting gridlock just because of population distribution in this country, he went on. As long as California and Wyoming have the same number of senators, theres going to be a problemunless were able to have a broader conversation and move people who right now arent voting for progressive policies and candidates. . . . All of this requires vigilance in protecting gains weve made, but a sense, yes, of equanimity, a sense of purposeful calm and optimism, and a sense of humorsometimes gallows humor after results like the ones we just had. Thats how ultimately the race is won.
...The Trump era confronted the outgoing President with obvious questions. Who was now the leader of the opposition and of the Democratic Party? What if there were violent racial incidents? Would he step in as a spokesman, a moral voice? Because of the demands of the transition and the tradition of discretion, Obama seemed unwilling to address these issues head on, but, at least in general terms, there was no question that he was now seeing his post-Presidency in a new, if dimmer, light. I think that if Hillary Clinton had won the election then Id just turn over the keys, he said. Wed make sure the briefing books were in order and out we go. I think now I have some responsibility to at least offer my counsel to those who will continue to be elected officials about how the D.N.C. can help rebuild, how state parties and progressive organizations can work together.
Trump had triumphed in rural America by appealing to a ferment of anti-urban, anti-coastal feeling. And yet Obama dismissed the notion that the Republicans had captured the issue of inequality. The Republicans dont care about that issue, he said. Theres no pretense that anything that theyre putting forward, any congressional proposals that are going to come forward, will reduce inequality. . . . What I do concern myself with, and the Democratic Party is going to have to concern itself with, is the fact that the confluence of globalization and technology is making the gap between rich and poor, the mismatch in power between capital and labor, greater all the time. And thats true globally.
The prescription that some offer, which is stop trade, reduce global integration, I dont think is going to work, he went on. If thats not going to work, then were going to have to redesign the social compact in some fairly fundamental ways over the next twenty years. And I know how to build a bridge to that new social compact. It begins with all the things weve talked about in the pastearly-childhood education, continuous learning, job training, a basic social safety net, expanding the earned-income tax credit, investments in infrastructurewhich, by definition, arent shipped overseas. All of those things accelerate growth, give you more of a runway. But at some point, when the problem is not just Uber but driverless Uber, when radiologists are losing their jobs to A.I., then were going to have to figure out how do we maintain a cohesive society and a cohesive democracy in which productivity and wealth generation are not automatically linked to how many hours you put in, where the links between production and distribution are broken, in some sense. Because I can sit in my office, do a bunch of stuff, send it out over the Internet, and suddenly I just made a couple of million bucks, and the person whos looking after my kid while Im doing that has no leverage to get paid more than ten bucks an hour.
The sense that, on the level of politics and policy, there was work to be done (I know how to build a bridge to that new social compact) infused the post-Presidential role that he sketched for himself. Ill be fifty-five when I leavehe knocked on a wooden end tableassuming that I get a couple more decades of good health, at least, then I think both Michelle and I are interested in creating platforms that train, empower, network, boost the next generation of leadership. And I think that, whatever shape my Presidential center takes, Im less interested in a building and campaign posters and Michelles dresses, although I think its fair to say that Michelles dresses will be the biggest draw by a huge margin. But what well be most interested in is programming that helps the next Michelle Obama or the next Barack Obama, who right now is sitting out there and has no idea how to make their ideals live, isnt quite sure what to doto give them resources and ways to think about social change.
He seemed to be returning to the days when he was a community organizer in the Altgeld Gardens housing project, on the South Side of Chicago. The thing that I have always been convinced of, he said, the running thread through my career, has been this notion that when ordinary people get engaged, pay attention, learn about the forces that affect their lives and are able to join up with others, good stuff happens.
Every ex-Presidency is marked, of course, by the Presidential memoir, and Obama acknowledged that the genre has been vexed. My observation in reading Presidential memoirs is that they are very heavy on and then this happened, and then that happened, he said. He noted that he hadnt managed to keep a diary in the White House and marvelled at the remarkable discipline that Jimmy Carter apparently had where each day he was describing what he had for breakfast and what happened here and what happened there. He admitted that as a writer he could never be as free as he was in his first book, Dreams from My Father. Some of it is just by virtue of decorum, he said. If you have meetings with people that theyve assumed were private and suddenly youre just spilling the beans, its a little bit like telling on an old girlfriend about something.
Shortly after four, following nearly two hours of conversation, Obama got up to call it a day. He would get some rest over the weekendhe played golf on Saturday and Sundaythen leave for the trip to Europe and South America on Monday. Along the way, he knew, his job was to keep offering reassurance, to deny the prospect of apocalypse, just as he had with his staff. This would require some doing, as his successors transition team already showed signs of chaotic infighting and of favoring many of the reactionaries, climate-change deniers, and heroes of the alt-right in their midst. On his first stop, in Athens, Obama would give a speech about populism, nationalism, globalization, tribalism, and, by implication, the ominous rise of Donald Trump.
Walking out the gates of the White House, I thought about the morning at Arlington. The weather was sunny, crisp, cool; dried leaves, russet and umber, skittered across the walk. It reminded me of Election Day eight years ago, in Chicago. Obama had voted near his house, on the South Side, and then accepted victory that night, flanked by his wife and daughters, in Grant Park. While the Democratic Party has won a great victory tonight, he had told the crowd of nearly a quarter-million people, we do so with a measure of humility and determination to heal the divides that have held back our progress. And he cited words that Abraham Lincoln spoke to a nation far more divided than ours: We are not enemies but friends. Though passion may have strained, it must not break our bonds of affection.
Obama, graying now, more exhausted than he admits, carried the wreath at Arlington to the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier: Here Rests in Honored Glory an American Soldier Known But to God. As a bugler played Taps, the realization came that in the coming year it would be Trump, formerly of Trump Taj Mahal, at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. Donald Trump, formerly the host of Celebrity Apprentice and the owner of Trump University, in the Situation Room. At 10 Downing Street. At the Élysée Palace. At the Gate of Heavenly Peace.
In the speech at Arlington that morning, Obama managed to deliver a political message. And this time he went beyond the call for orderly transitions and praise for excellent meetings. He delivered a distinct paean to values that Trump so often dismissed.
Veterans Day often follows a hard-fought political campaign, an exercise in the free speech and self-government that you fought for, he said. It often lays bare disagreements across our nation. But the American instinct has never been to find isolation in opposite corners. It is to find strength in our common creed, to forge unity from our great diversity, to sustain that strength and unity even when it is hard.
Its the example of the single most diverse institution in our countrysoldiers, sailors, airmen, marines, and coastguardsmen who represent every corner of our country, every shade of humanity, immigrant and native-born, Christian, Muslim, Jew, and nonbeliever alike, all forged into common service. His sober cadences gave resonance to words that could have been rote. So did the awareness that just seventy days remained of his Presidency.
Here was the hopeful vision of diversity and dignity that Obama had made his own, and hearing these words I couldnt help remembering how he began his victory speech eight years ago. If there is anyone out there who still doubts that America is a place where all things are possible, he said, tonight is your answer. A very different answer arrived this Election Day. America is indeed a place where all things are possible: that is its greatest promise and, perhaps, its gravest peril.
Help
