Minorwood continuation
#1
Posted 2013-March-04, 06:57
In particular, you're dealt:
J
AKQJ8
AQ86
A97
Partner opens 1D, and after a 4th suit auction you've bid 4D as RKCB. How do you continue? You're playing matchpoints in a strong field, so getting to 7NT will be good if you can.
#2
Posted 2013-March-04, 07:37
#3
Posted 2013-March-05, 03:32
#4
Posted 2013-March-05, 07:36
#5
Posted 2013-March-06, 11:20
#6
Posted 2013-March-06, 11:30
#7
Posted 2013-March-07, 03:18
fromageGB, on 2013-March-06, 11:20, said:
There are two schemes I am used to. So diamonds are trumps and you ask with 5 club:
1.
5 ♦ no king
5 ♥ heart king 5 spades asks: 5 NT king of spades, 6♣ king of clubs
5 ♠ Spade king, no heart king 5 Nt ask for club king 6 ♣ yes
5 NT club king no major king 6 ♣ anything else?
5 ♦ no king
5 ♥ Heart king or both black kings
5♠ Spade king or heart+ club King
5 NT Club king or major kings
Usually the second scheme works better. I never had a problem here to identify the kings.
Roland
Sanity Check: Failure (Fluffy)
More system is not the answer...
#8
Posted 2013-March-07, 04:03
JLOGIC, on 2013-March-06, 11:30, said:
I do not do anything "clever" here, just use Roland's first scheme because the rules for it are simple and work across other auctions. You are right that 5♦ as no king is probably not optimal though. Your suggestion for 5♦ to show the ♣K looks pretty good to me and makes for an easy rule adjustment that is still portable across all auctions. I might just steal that from you...
If I remember the last discussion we had on this subject, there was a suggestion for using king denials which worked out slightly more efficient than the normal shows; but I did not think the benefit was enough to offset the potential for confusion. I would assume that something like that would be the absolute optimumm here.
#9
Posted 2013-March-07, 05:53
some players also play next suit as Queen ask bid.
#10
Posted 2013-March-07, 06:22
If play that,the methods are at below:
1-if 4♣ is minorwood,5♦ should be a king asking bid.
2-if 4♦ is minorwood,5♥ should be a king asking bid.however 5♣ is a cuebid to show ♣K .
Now I have to say 4nt is a terminal bid to play after respond to a minorwood.
#11
Posted 2013-March-08, 11:05
The 5H bid should ask for Kings and shows all the keycards including the D Queen (5NT shows the H King or the two black kings and 6D denies a king).
#12
Posted 2013-March-08, 11:43
ucrman, on 2013-March-08, 11:05, said:
mr1303, on 2013-March-04, 06:57, said:
#13
Posted 2013-March-08, 11:49
ucrman, on 2013-March-08, 11:05, said:
That is normally the case.
But here partner replied 4NT = 3rd step , 2 - ♦Q .
'asker':
J
AKQJ8
AQ86
A97
So a cheaper K-ask step is available, namely 5C.
I play it as asking for specific Kings( I think easier on the memory cells )
Replies:
5D = no outside Kings
5H = ♥-K
5S = ♠-K but no ♥K
5NT = ♣-K but no Major K
If partner replied 5S, then 5NT = a 2nd K-ask.
...... 6C would then show the ♣K and you now have enough for a grand slam : 7NT
........... counting 2s, 5h, 4+d, 2c
...... If no ♣K, then 6D would be the reply to the 2nd K-ask .
TWOferBRIDGE
"imo by far in bridge the least understood concept is how to bid over a jump-shift
( 1M-1NT!-3m-?? )." ....Justin Lall
" Did someone mention relays? " .... Zelandakh
K-Rex to Mikeh : " Sometimes you drive me nuts " .